Side-by-Side Comparison of Optimization Capabilities

Excel Solver vs. Premium Solver

Below is a side-by-side comparison of our basic Solver for Mac and our new Premium Solver Platform for Mac. Despite all the additional power and flexibility your current models, and VBA code, will work as is and it still uses the Solver interface you are already familiar with.

 

Standard Excel Solver

Premium Solver Platform

FEATURES AND PERFORMANCE

Optimization

Optimization

Psi Technology:

 
 

Find linear, nonlinear, nonsmooth formulas

 

Yes

Determine whether model is convex

 

Yes

"Linearize" IF, MIN, MAX, ABS, logical formulas

 

Yes

 
 
 

Built-in Engines:

 
 

Simplex Linear Solver

LP Only

LP/Quadratic

GRG Nonlinear Solver

Yes

Yes (faster)

Mixed-Integer Solver

Yes

Yes (faster)

Evolutionary Solver

Yes

Yes (faster)

SOCP Barrier Solver

 

Yes

Field-Installable Solver Engines

 

Yes1

 
 
 

Optimization Problem Size:

 
 

Linear Variables x Constraints

200 x 200

8000 x 8000

Nonlinear Variables x Constraints

200 x 100

500 x 250

Non-Smooth Variables x Constraints

 

500 x 250

Integer Constraints on Variables

200

2000

Solver Engine Variables x Constraints

 

Unlim x Unlim

 
 
 

Speed (approximate):

 
 

Problem Setup

1X

2-100X

Linear Problems

1X

20X

Nonlinear Problems

1X

7-15X

Mixed-Integer Problems

1X

10-200X

Non-Smooth Problems

1X

1-10X

Solver Engines (On Various Problems)

 

10-1000X

 
 
 

Variables and Constraints:

 
 

Normal Decision Variables

Yes

Yes

Normal, Integer, and Binary Constraints

Yes

Yes

Semi-continuous Constraints

 

Yes

All-different Constraints

 

Yes

Second Order Cone Constraints

 

Yes

 
 
 

Global Optimization:

 
 

Non-Smooth Problems (Evolutionary)

Yes

Yes

Nonlinear Problems (Multistart)

 

Yes

Solver Engines (Several Approaches)

 

Yes

 
 
 

Constraint Programming and Conic Optimization:

 
 

Built-In Engines (alldifferent constraints)

 

Yes

Built-In Engines (second order cone constraints)

 

Yes

Solver Engines (alldifferent and cone constraints)

 

Yes

 
 
 

Solver Reports:

 
 

Answer Report

Yes

Yes

Sensitivity Report

Yes

Yes

Limits Report

Yes

Yes

Linearity Report

Yes

Yes

Feasibility Report

Yes

Yes

Population Report

Yes

Yes

Report Outlining

Yes

Yes

Block Selection and Comments

 

Yes

Solutions Report

 

Yes

Scaling Report

 

Yes

Structure/Convexity Report

 

Yes

Transformation Report

 

Yes

1 Premium Solver Platform for the Mac includes the Large-Scale LP/QP, MOSEK, Gurobi, Large-Scale GRG and KNITRO Solver engines.

Try Premium Solver Platform for Mac for Free!

The best way to decide whether Premium Solver Platform for Mac is for you is to try it out! You can use it for Free for 15 days with no cost, obligation, or any payment information required up front.

And the trial version allows you to use every feature of the software, solve real problems, examine the full User Guide and Help, and even get expert technical support -- all without any obligation.

Just complete the form below, company and phone are optional, and click Register for Download. You can then immediately download after registering, or return later anytime -- just login with your email address.